Mulan Essay - 1541 Words

The representation of women in Disney films has indefinitely transformed throughout the decades due to Disney’s need to gradually create conventional views and ideas of women. When comparing the 1998 Disney film, Mulan, and the 2016 Disney film, Moana, people may suggest that both are progressive feminist films that accurately depict their individual cultures, while uplifting the women in these films. However, with further analysis, Mulan consists of not only sexist views towards women, but also underlines stereotypical gender roles that men are greater than women. Moreover, Moana reflects a change of the conventional woman in Disney films by rejecting the female stereotypes as well as creating a headstrong and independent character who†¦show more content†¦In the journal article, Images of Gender, Race, Age, and Sexual Orientation in Disney Feature-Length Animated Films, Mia Adessa Towbin , Shelley A. Haddock , Toni Schindler Zimmerman , Lori K. Lund and Litsa Renee Tanner argue, â€Å"In Mulan, Asian culture is mostly presented in a realistic and positive manner, although some negative stereotypic attributes are given to the â€Å"bad guys.† Mulan is the first animated Disney film to attempt to accurately depict Asian culture† (37). However, some argue that Mulan is actually not a realistic depiction of Chinese culture. Chyng Feng Sun in Mickey Mouse Monopoly asserts, â€Å"In order to create this model of a feminist figure, China is portrayed as probably the most sexist and oppressive society†¦ And we hear people say women have no value at all if they dont get married. And the interesting thing is this matchmaking interviews in the movie did not actually exist in China. And it has been made very clear that women should just follow mens’ orders instead of speaking up their minds in their society† (00:32:37). To showcase Chyng Feng Sun’s statement, in the film, Chi Fu says, â€Å"Silence! You will do we ll to teach your daughter to hold her tongue in a man’s presence† (00:15:26). These examples illuminate the various opinions on whether Mulan is actually a film that encourages theShow MoreRelatedThe Life of Mulan Essay1471 Words   |  6 Pagescomrades were amazed and perplexed to find out that he was in fact, a woman, (Kington). You might know whom I am talking about. Her name was Fa Mulan. After hearing the story about Mulan, I spent some time thinking about what it meant for a woman in ancient China to transcend beyond the boundaries of gender and culture for family, honor, and duty. Mulan became a true warrior - one who encompassed not only the combatant and the housewife but the struggle between them as well. Perhaps it is becauseRead MoreMulan Essay943 Words   |  4 PagesThe film Mulan is set in ancient China, in an undefined dynasty. The Huns have penetrated the Great Wall and have invaded China. The emperor orders that new soldiers be drafted. Mulan, a girl who recently humiliated her family by failing the Matchmaker’s assessment, in order to save her aging father from death at war, steals her father’s armor and masquerades as a soldier. Throughout the film, several historical inaccuracies, as well as accurate portrayals, become apparent, in such respects as religiousRead MoreMulan As A Hero Essay1447 Words   |  6 Pagestaking risks, taking yo urself out of your comfort zone, and making the effort to try and do everything you can. At times this can even mean sacrifice to a certain extent, especially for someone you care for. Mulan is the ideal example for this characteristic, and what heroism is overall. Mulan, a young girl from China, was faced with an interesting, but tough situation. When her weak, injured father was given a conscription to go into war for the Emperor of China, she begged the council memberRead MoreMulan Monomyth Essay1939 Words   |  8 PagesMulan is the ultimate epitome of a hero. Joseph Cambell who said â€Å"A hero is someone who has given his or her life to something bigger than oneself† , characterizes Mulan to perfection. She undergoes changes throughout struggles which shape her into the worthy hero that she is. . Mulan faces both inner and outer battles that transform her persona to being a hero. According to Joseph Cambell’s monomyth, Mulan meets the necessary qualities, as she portrays them grandly It allRead MoreMulan: A Woman on a Mission Essay1816 Words   |  8 PagesMulan (Revised) Disney proclaims that the adaptations of the Chinese story of Mulan is to transform ethnic materials into a â€Å"timeless† or â€Å"universal† classic (Kurtti 1998). Peter Schneider, Disney Feature Animation President, avers that â€Å"the search for who we are, the search for self, it an ever-ongoing process and universal theme† (Kurtti 1998, 189). Guided by this principle, Disney appropriated the Mulan story into its typical formula of a hero’s journey of self-discovery. The film featuresRead More Traditional Western and Disney Ideals as Seen in Mulan Essay2965 Words   |  12 Pages Traditional Western and Disney Ideals as Seen in Mulan Fairy tales have been a long tradition in almost all cultures, starting as oral traditions to and gradually evolving into written texts intended for future generations to enjoy. Today, a common medium for relaying these ancient stories is through animation. The Walt Disney Company is probably the most well known for its animated portrayals of many classic fairy tales. These fairy tales are considered, by fairy tale researcher Justyna DeszczRead MoreEssay On The Princess Who Stood By Jeane Desy1419 Words   |  6 PagesFinal Essay Test Many early fairy tales adhere to a patriarchal bias within their storytelling. The patriarchy can be defined as a social system that values the needs, voices and lives of men over those of women. As social norms change and evolve over time, so have fairy tales with their revisions as they tackle the traditional yet outdated patriarchal perspectives of their predecessors. Nevertheless, despite their good intentions, certain revisionist tales fail to dismiss this patriarchal biasRead MoreThe Wife, The Undutiful Spouse, And Bad Mother Essay1702 Words   |  7 Pagesfeminist, was considered as the first woman had been aware of this education problem in the late 19th century of China. She had received both traditional education and modern education. She has written an essay called â€Å" An Address to My Two Hundred Millions Women Compatriots in China†. In this essay, she talks about the inequity of men and women. Moreover, she shows her awareness of independence of woman. She ask ed all the women in this country to be useful, not like men’s dolls. During her time, womenRead MoreAnalysis Of Mulan s A Prince Will Come And Save You1610 Words   |  7 PagesMulan was filmed in 1998 during the third wave of feminism, which is the â€Å"advocacy of women s rights on the grounds of political, social, and economic equality to men† (dictionary). Mulan isn’t a typical princess, but a women who saves her father from going to war with the Huns. Disney does stray away from the typical â€Å"damsel in distress† storyline and brings a new foundation of ideas to the big screen. Where Sleeping Beauty the idea of â€Å"a prince will come† and save you, to Mulan who challengesRead MoreOne Woman Rescues An Entire Nation : Mulan Defies Traditional Gender1106 Words   |  5 PagesOne Woman Rescues an Entire Nation: Mulan Defies Traditional Gender Roles Becomes a Hero What does it mean to be a man or woman, girl or boy? Who creates these gender constraints and reinforces these roles within a society? Gender is a social construct that is manufactured by the media in order to guide the masses towards thinking and behaving in a way that is perceived to be accurate. â€Å"Gender is not something we are born with, and not something we have, but something we do—something we perform†